Showing posts with label Barth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barth. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Barth's Calvin

It was an really interesting book, in part because Barth gives a biography of Calvin. There are also some quotes I'm interested in relating, from Theology o John Calvin. On p.22, speaking of Thomas Aquinas: "We have in his case a demonstration how often even the greatest among us, precisely in fulfilling their deepest intentions, often do not know what they are doing. The reformers engaged in close combat with late scholastics of the age of decline, about whom we say nothing today, when all the time behind these, and biding his time, stood their main adversary Thomas..." on p. 36, in talking about medieval theology, "It is the harmony of the monastery garden with its rows of cherry trees and its splashing fountains and its surrounding walls that remind us of the world with its joy and grief but also shut it out." I will be asking myself whether in my own research I try to shut out the world. and Finally, on p. 246, "God demands of us a double brokenness, the first by way of the insight that God alone is great and that w can do nothing for him and for our own justification, the second by way of the insight that we must obey this great God in faith either by what we do not do or by what we do, but at all events that we must obey him if we really believe." Something to think over if you believe, as I do, that everyone has a unique contribution to make.

I also read my partner Tony's eclectic reading: something about a British Library report on young readers who use the Internet. There are a few myths: youngsters trust authority figures more than the Internet; they are not good searchers but know only a few simple applications; they are not actually more impatient. There was also a disquisition on Obama becoming inevitably the black candidate, and not simply a candidate, and another article about lack of content in the Democratic party; a complaint about a chain of British pub that limit the drinks for people accompanied by children; an obit for Suzanne Pleshette; a discussion of whether Vladimir Nabokov's dying wish to destroy a part of a novel should be respected by his son; a history of marriage and a history of the medical clinic; a discussion of Heidegger's early article on poetry; and reviews of books on shyness and eloquence (they worked, I'll read the books).

Friday, January 11, 2008

Barth's Witness to the Word, Ethics, Theology of the Reformed Confessions

With Ethics, I've read about a dozen books that were originally lectures for courses by various intellectuals: Maritain, Heidegger, and now Barth. He takes a highly abstract view of ethics, and doesn't even get to the concept of conscience until very late in the book, as he himself states. The other two books are very technical: Witness is actually a commentary on the first chapter of the Gospel according to John, such as the commentary of Romans that made Barth famous. I was handicapped in my appreciation by my lack of Greek, but it was extremely technical at best. Theology of the Reformed Confessions referred constantly to texts that I was not knowledgeable about, like the various catechisms and professions of faith of the Protestant denominations.

I also read a number of articles on air power in the latest Air and Aerospace Journal, as well as the latest issue of Vanity Fair cover to cover, but back to front.

Thursday, January 10, 2008

Karl Barth's Final Testimonies and German Church in Conflict, Popper's Myth of Framework

When reading this collection of essays (London: Routledge, 1994) by Popper, I found an excellent summary of Popper's thought over the books I've already read. I also asked myself some questions regarding the refutability of my work. Do I know what evidence would constitute a refutation of my general theory of strategy? Yes, the choice of the indirect strategy by some actor who should choose a direct strategy. Are those categories of values and type of strategy distinct? Yes. Is it possible to select only some evidence in case studies in order to find what I wish to find? Yes, but that is possible in any case. Is there an additional danger in self-fulfilling prophecies because values have to be a relative judgment? Yes, but it is possible to guard against it.

Well, I'm glad I thought it all over. There were some quotes of interest to me. On p. 34, "I hold that orthodoxy is the death of knowledge, since the growth of knowledge depends entirely on the existence of disagreement." On p. 60, "we...can logically distinguish between a mistaken method of criticizing and a correct method of criticizing. The mistaken method starts from the question: how can we establish or justify our thesis or our theory? It thereby leads either to dogmatism, or to an infinite regress, or to the relativistic doctrine of rationally incommensurable frameworks. By contrast, the correct method of critical discussion starts from the question; What are the consequences of our thesis or our theory? Are they all acceptable to us?" On p. 70, "I used to warn my students against the widespread idea that one goes to college in order to learn how to talk and write 'impressively' and incomprehensibly." And finally, on p. 72, that some leaders of German sociology 'who do their intellectual best, and do it with the best conscience in the world, are nevertheless, I believe, simply taking trivialities in high-sounding language, as they were taught. They teach this to their students, who are dissatisfied, yet do the same. The genuine and general feeling of dissatisfaction, manifest in their hostility to the society in which they live, is a reflection of their unconscious dissatisfaction with the sterility of their own activities."

Barth's German Church Conflict is a collection of essays written during the rise of National Socialism in Germany in the 30s. They were brave, although Barth was protected to some extent by his Swiss nationality, but he was nonetheless deported for them from his home of 13 years, in Bonn. Final Testimonies is an assortment of less important transcriptions of last interviews and talks. Some of it is quite moving, particularly the quotation about Christ: "In him is the spur to work, warfare, and fellowship. In him is all that I have attempted in my life in weakness and folly." That is from p. 30 of my edition (Grand Rapids: Eeardmans, 1972), and it ought also to be my epitaph.

Wednesday, December 26, 2007

Karl Barth's Epistle to the Romans

Having read a good deal of Barth, I was curious to read this, his first book, the book which established his reputation. It certainly leaps off the page even today as a mystical commentary on Saint Paul, and was way ahead of its time in terms of what he understood it to mean for society, the individual, and the churches. After reading this, I have concluded that the problems of the churches which profess Christianity but do not seem to me to be living the values they talk about were in every way predictable and foreseeable through exegesis. That certainly comes as a surprise, although I'm also relieved to hear about it. I also came to realize in reading this last book, and the first volume of Pickwick Papers, that I read in part to feel a call to become something more than I am. Funny it took me so many books to understand that. Barth also discusses how the people of Israel come to sin because of their special vocation, a variation on 'to whom much is given, much will be asked.' Since I feel very fortunate in my life, this is not an entirely comfortable conclusion to read about. On both these points, Barth suggests that we need to fashion ourselves not according to the present world, but according to its transformation.

Karl Barth's Evangelical Theology

I read this book with an eye to seeing if there was anything he said about a theologian that also applies to the life of a university professor. As it turns out, there was. "...all theological work can be undertaken and accomplished only amid great distress, which assails it on all sides. ...theological work should be boldly begun and carried forward because, hidden in the great distress in which alone it can take place, its still greater hope and impulse are present." (p. 159) Yes, I do my work in hope -- disappointed often in some ways, and romantic in others, but hope nonetheless. On p. 165, Barth says that for the theologian, the 'only possible procedure every day, in fact every hour, is to begin anew at the beginning. An in this respect theological work can be exemplary for all intellectual work. Yesterday's memories can be comforting and encouraging for such work only if they are identical with the recollection that this work, even yesterday, had to begin at the beginning and, it is to be hoped, actually began there." There was also truth and similarities when Barth says that 'theological study and the impulse which compels it are not passing stages of life." (p. 172) Later on the same page he says that 'When properly understood, an examination is a friendly conversation of older students of theology with younger ones, concerting certain themes in which they share a common interest. Th e purpose of this conversation is to give younger participants an opportunity to exhibit themselves, and to what extent they appear to give promise of doing so in the future. The real value of a doctorate, even when earned with the greatest distinction, is totally dependent on the degree to which its recipient has conducted and maintained himself as a learner." I love it! This is the spirit of the university!

Then Barth speaks of what study is about: first, the student, young or old, has to inquire directly into what his predecessors had to say to the world, to the community of the present, and to himself as a member of that community. Then the student must allow himself indirectly to be given the necessary directions and admonitions for the journey toward the answer which he seeks. These instructions are gained from the theologians of the past, the recent past, and form his immediate antecedents. No one should imagine himself so inspired or clever and wise that he can conduct the primary discussion by his own powers.

Dickens, Barth

I have read Nicholas Nickleby, which I thought was masterful. I'm going to have to read Pickwick Papers shortly, which has failed to capture my examination. I also read Protestant Theology in the 19th Century, which was full of references to theologians of whom I had never heard. I also read Knowledge of God and Service of God by Karl Barth. I read Diane Paxson's Ravens of Avalon, which was a gift. It was the story of Bodacia, the queen who defeated the Romans in England.

Protestant Theology had some quotes I'd like to share. The first is something I'll reuse, I'm sure. "The Reader is invited to reflect on the omissions. He will find all sorts of gaps that I would not leave open today, and accents which I would now place differently. ... And he will probably stumble on one or other error of interpretation or judgment, caused by the haste in which I had to work and, at a deeper level, by limits to my vision." (p. 11, London: SCM Press, 1972).

"For fundamentally the astonishing thing is not that Hegel believed his philosophy to be an unsurpassable climax and culmination. It is that he was not right in thinking that after him the development was possible of a school of positivism, of pessimism and even of materialism, of Neo-Kantianism and whatever else the other modern philosophies may be called." (p. 384)

Sunday, December 23, 2007

Barth, Dickens

I have read three of Karl Barth's books: Word of God and Word of Man, a bunch of homilies; Credo, a summary of his doctrinal beliefs; Community, State, and Church, three essays. None of them made a big impression on me, but then I read the volumes of Church Dogmatics. I also read Dickens' Bleak House, which I found not remarkable, and Little Dorritt, which I enjoyed more despite its now cliche plot. I am reading Pickwick Papers right now, as a break from Maritain. I also collected about 60 articles to read for my project on counterterrorism.

Wednesday, December 19, 2007

Karl Barth's Dogmatics in Outline and Christian Life

In the case of both these books, I was quite taken by the sincerity and simplicity of the forewords. For Dogmatics in Outline, it was the revealing that the book was born from lectures given in 1946 Germany, in the semi-ruins of a formerly glorious Schloss where the University of Bonn had relocated, to the sounds of bulldozers, and after singing a hymn or psalm "to cheer ourselves up." I can only imagine the challenges of lecturing in such a setting, and at such a time. In the case of Christian Life, it was the student-published notes from public lectures given by Barth, who evidently gave in to over-enthusiastic and persistent audience members, and implored the reader not to expect the rigor of theology, but to accept as such 'merely what was offered.' Having read the multi-volume Church Dogmatics previously, I did not find any material that was new in these charmingly-introduced little books.