Showing posts with label Montesquieu. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Montesquieu. Show all posts
Monday, January 14, 2008
Montesquieu's Pensees, Vanity Fair and the New Yorker, and Fair's Cooperation with Pakistan and India
Pensees was interesting primarily int eh sections on literature and writing. Montesquieu candidly admits that he is afflicted with wanting passionately to write books and then being embarrassed by them. I felt comforted in my writer's soul! I too writhe in the night at the thought of some of my own mistakes, enshrined with finality in print. After that, I read Christine Fair's study of counter terrorism, Cooperation with Pakistan and India. This is a Rand study for the US air force, and contains some policy recommendations that struck me as basic and obvious, but useful nonetheless to the lay audience of the air force.
I have decided from now on to list the magazines I read. I won't discuss OK Magazine, which I consider entertainment on a par with junk food, but I did read Vanity Fair and the New Yorker. I love the New Yorker for its long articles on sometimes arcane subjects. This time it was the business of scrap metal, about which I knew nothing. The review section I always read as well, although I skip contemporary music. I skip the fiction and the poetry, dare I say it! Vanity Fair was a little thin, but Dominic Dunne is as self absorbed as ever, the read all about the Birley will contest in London (about the estate of the owner of the nightclub Annabel's), I was riveted by Karl Rove's Proust Questionnaire -- I despise the man's political tactics, but he makes a good pundit in general -- I reveled in the Scaife divorce exercise of 'he said, she said'. Can I spell Schadenfreude? I was bored with the umpteenth sussing of Princess Diana's inquest. There, I had a good time reading a certain level of trash. I routinely also read the New Scientist.
I have decided from now on to list the magazines I read. I won't discuss OK Magazine, which I consider entertainment on a par with junk food, but I did read Vanity Fair and the New Yorker. I love the New Yorker for its long articles on sometimes arcane subjects. This time it was the business of scrap metal, about which I knew nothing. The review section I always read as well, although I skip contemporary music. I skip the fiction and the poetry, dare I say it! Vanity Fair was a little thin, but Dominic Dunne is as self absorbed as ever, the read all about the Birley will contest in London (about the estate of the owner of the nightclub Annabel's), I was riveted by Karl Rove's Proust Questionnaire -- I despise the man's political tactics, but he makes a good pundit in general -- I reveled in the Scaife divorce exercise of 'he said, she said'. Can I spell Schadenfreude? I was bored with the umpteenth sussing of Princess Diana's inquest. There, I had a good time reading a certain level of trash. I routinely also read the New Scientist.
Labels:
2008,
Fair,
Montesquieu,
New Yorker for Jan 14,
Vanity Fair for Feb
Thursday, January 3, 2008
Montesquieu's defense of Esprit des lois
Since I have to travel and will be sitting at a sick relative's bedside, without talking to allow him to rest, I took off to the library and got Jean-Jacques Rousseau's complete works and Montesquieu's complete works. At the bottom of my sixteen page reading list was to read the complete works of anyone whom the Pleiade thought worthy of publishing. (Pleiade is a collection that publishes the works of luminaries from all cultures, but in French. It's a famous collection in the francophone word, and, indeed, Pleiade is the French name of a great constellation. Love it! ) Because of personal circumstances, I jumped right to it for the time being.
I was reading the second volume of Montesquieu, since I had already read Esprit des lois and expected to whiz through the other books in the same volume. I was right: I read his essays on taste, and his files in preparation for writing Esprit, and then I also read his replies to his critics after publication.
That alone was worth the price of admission! Montesquieu has done what I have often wanted to do, that is, reply to my critics with nary a concern for their feelings of being thought arrogant. On p. 1161 of my edition, he says "Quand on critique un ouvrage, et un grand ouvrage, il faut tacher de se procurer une connaissance particuliere de la science qui y est traitee, et bien lire les auteurs approuves qui ont deja ecrit sur cette science, afin de voir si l'auteur s'est ecarte de la maniere recue et ordinarie de la traiter." In other words, if one is going to criticize a great work, one should make sure that one understands the work thoroughly and to have also a thorough background, to see if the author has left the rails or not. Bull's eye! So many critics fail to take the time to understand what another person writes, or to be thorough even. There are exceptions, but no many.
I was reading the second volume of Montesquieu, since I had already read Esprit des lois and expected to whiz through the other books in the same volume. I was right: I read his essays on taste, and his files in preparation for writing Esprit, and then I also read his replies to his critics after publication.
That alone was worth the price of admission! Montesquieu has done what I have often wanted to do, that is, reply to my critics with nary a concern for their feelings of being thought arrogant. On p. 1161 of my edition, he says "Quand on critique un ouvrage, et un grand ouvrage, il faut tacher de se procurer une connaissance particuliere de la science qui y est traitee, et bien lire les auteurs approuves qui ont deja ecrit sur cette science, afin de voir si l'auteur s'est ecarte de la maniere recue et ordinarie de la traiter." In other words, if one is going to criticize a great work, one should make sure that one understands the work thoroughly and to have also a thorough background, to see if the author has left the rails or not. Bull's eye! So many critics fail to take the time to understand what another person writes, or to be thorough even. There are exceptions, but no many.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
